Before you read this, you’ve gotta understand that I don’t intend to offend anyone. Race is a touchy subject for everyone, but once in a while, you hear or see something that makes you think "How can people be so fucking stupid about such an inconsequential thing?" And its with that apology that we’ll start. Enough of this crap.
I was given this magazine at orientation called "RealizASIAN" (get it) and in this magazine was an article about how Asian men are viewed in the media. So I read it and was kind of confused. The article reads:
"Asian Men are often portrayed as feminine, weak, and introvert. Too frequently, Asian men are portrayed as not being able to speak English, the immigrant with the strong accent, the "silent kung fu" master or the evil "fu manchu" monster. Even the Kung Fu master which may appear to be a positive role, relegates actors into a emasculated exotic Asian (not Asian American male) role who never gets the girl"
All right, now first of all I'm pretty sure this guy has never seen a Jet Li movie. Or a Bruce Lee movie, for that matter. Or even a freaking Jackie Chan movie. If he had, he'd have realized that those stereotypes have more or less been crushed. Lets take the movie "War" for instance, the most recent Jet Li movie I've seen. It features Li as quite possibly the biggest badass ever and Mighty Whitey Jason Statham as his sexy counterpart. The movie features Li happily married with a beautiful Asian wife and adorable daughter. Then they get murdered and he spends most of the movie kicking the shit out of everyone who looks at him funny and getting revenge. Now you might say "wait just a second! That's one movie. The majority of the time, Asian men are weak and effeminate." Well guess what, that's basically the premise of all of his movies. Romeo Must Die even ends with Jet Li and Aaliyah together. Never getting the girl, my ass!
And lets not forget Bruce Lee. In Enter the Dragon, the badass black guy who was banging no less than seven girls at once gets killed by the main bad guy. Bruce on the other hand, nails the chick and kills the bad guy. It should be worth noting that Bruce Lee is the epitome of manly. Brad Pitt and Tom Cruse may be sex symbols, but Asian action stars are basically just testosterone in human form.
As for the thing about Asians who can't speak English, or being portrayed as the "delivery boy". How many people have ordered out Chinese food? You know how you know if the restaurant is going to be terrible? The person who takes your order is white. I'm worried when my waiter doesn't have an accent. I don't even see how that qualifies as something negative. If anything its accurate. I have plenty of Asian friends who's parents are from another country. They speak decent enough English, but at home they speak whatever their native language is. That doesn't just go for Asian friends. It goes for the Russians and the Serbians and any other ethnic family you can think of. Its the way things are, quit bitching about it.
I'm curious what he means by "Fu-Manchu" villain. Does this mean that any Asian villain is a Fu Manchu? What does he consider the slimy accountant Lao, from the new Batman movie? Is this villain a Fu-Manchu? Seriously, are the only movies that this guy has ever seen pre-1960?
I tried imagining the guy who wrote this crap. I came up with this: Age 20, 1.5 Generation Asian-American. Virgin. Has mostly Asian friends and is a giant, whiny pussy who is just looking for an excuse for why he can't find a girlfriend. I can't think of any other reason for him to be writing this when its just not the case.
Anyway, moving on in the article, I started reading about Asian female stereotypes.
"Asian/Asian American women have been portrayed in the media as aggressive sexual beings. Western film and literature has promoted hyper sexualized stereotypes of Asian women as cunning "Dragon Ladies", as servile "Lotus Blossom", "China Dolls", "Geisha Girls", "War Brides" or "Prostitutes.""
I love the slang this guy uses. "Dragon Ladies"... That's a new one. What the fuck is a "Lotus Blossom"? This guy must not like David Bowie too much...
I think I figured out the problem with this guy. He doesn't watch any mainstream films. In fact the only movies he watches are pornos. It would explain a lot. Like the reason he somehow thinks Asian men are only shown as effeminate or that Asian women are hyper sexual. Yeah, in porn this is definitely the case, but that's only because porn is made to please the majority, and the majority of the United States is not Asian. They go with the most common dick color so that more of the viewers can relate to the owner of said dick... Or something like that. Since porn is entirely fantasy, it goes without saying that the Asian girls are either going to be these super filthy temptresses or these docile girls. Its like that for any girl of any nationality in them. Its about turning people on, not meaningful cinema.
I watch a lot of movies, and I find that Asian girls are very, very physically attractive so when I see them on screen, I tend to remember their parts. All this docile and overly sexual crap, I just don't understand. Take Kill Bill for instance. Lucy Liu's character is a total badass. She is Uma Thurman's most worth opponent. She uses her sexuality once to get the jump on the mob boss who killed her parents, but she was 12 years old at the time and the mob boss just happened to be a pedophile. Yeah, that's a real "Dragon Lady" right there.
Even her henchwoman Go-Go, who constantly dresses like a school girl doesn't really fit into the category. In her opening scene, she asks a creepy old man if he wants to screw her. When he says yes, she immediately impales him and tears open his stomach. Nothing subtle about it, nothing sexy. She was just drunk and sadistic. Later on she pounds Uma Thurman's pretty hard. With a mace.
I'm not saying that every movie is going to have Asian women in strong roles. The same goes for men too. The point is that for every movie with a negative stereotype, another one can be found with more positive aspects. And lets face it, everyone gets their share of stereotypes in movies. It doesn't matter what race, religion or gender you are, its gonna happen.
The name of the magazine, as previously stated is "RealizASIAN", so its pretty obvious who the audience is. I really can't stand stuff like this. Groups that are based entirely off race. I understand the appeal. Its your own culture so its only natural to gravitate towards the familiar. The thing I don't like about it is how much it goes against what I was raised to believe and I guess what I consider to be the "American Way".
There's a song from School House Rock called "The Great American Melting Pot" that my 7th grade social studies teacher played to our class. Its a real term that describes how Americans are essentially a blending of every culture. I think that's the way it should be. If we all simply take everyone and indiscriminately thrust them together, its a lot easier to accept their difference. My teacher disagreed. He thought that rather than a melting pot, it should be "The Great American Salad Bowl", every culture is still together, but they all keep their individual shapes and forms. Aside from sounding incredibly lame, its also not a very good concept. The reason for this is that we are Americans. America was founded by basically, Europe's rejects. Some of them were English, some of them were French, some of them were Irish, etc etc. The point is, that they gave up their culture when they came to the United States.
My Grandfather moved here in the 1920s from Vienna. After about ten years, he settled down with an American girl, had two kids and eventually retired very happy. He kept some things from the old country, but for the most part he was absorbed into the American culture. He never forbid his daughter from dating non-Jews, and he had a great deal of non-European friends. He certainly never based his opinion of someone based on their native origin.
We have freedom of speech in the States, which is why a magazine like this one can exist. It seems sort of like biting the hand that feeds you though. For the most part all of these kids were either born in America or moved to America at a young enough age that they were educated here. Rather than becoming part of the society, they self segregate by surrounding themselves with only those of a similar backgrounds and bitch and moan about how everyone perceives them a certain way, never really dealing with other races on a personal level and ignoring the fact that everyone is stereotyped inaccurately, especially in film, no exceptions. Its not just Asians. I know plenty of Jews like this and I'm sure its true for everyone that gets such a large part of their identity from something as trivial as race.
The Great American Melting Pot was a good idea because it supports mixing it up. If you go with the Salad Bowl idea, it really defeats the whole premise of America and the term "United We Stand" because that isn't unity. Its self regulated segregation. Rather than have a magazine that's specifically for Asians, or whatever the race, I'd rather see something broader and vague. Just take one big-ass magazine and entitle it "It sucks getting stereotyped in the media and here's why: A magazine for everyone".